Identify and correct pronoun errors with ‘who’

  1. Understanding ‘Who’
  • ‘Who’ is a pronoun used to refer to people, specifically as the subject of a sentence or clause. It is often used to ask questions or introduce relative clauses.
    Examples:
  • Who is calling?
  • The person who won the race is my friend.

  1. ‘Who’ as a Subject Pronoun
  • ‘Who’ is always used as the subject of a verb, meaning it performs the action in the sentence.
    Examples:
  • Who called you?
  • The student who answered the question was correct.
  • Common Error: Using ‘who’ where an object pronoun (like ‘whom’) should be used.
  • Incorrect: The teacher asked who the message was for.
  • Correct: The teacher asked whom the message was for.

  1. ‘Who’ vs. ‘Whom’
  • Use ‘who’ when the pronoun is the subject of a verb (the person doing the action).
  • Example: Who is going to the party?
    (Here, ‘who’ is the subject of the verb ‘is going’).
  • Use ‘whom’ when the pronoun is the object of a verb or preposition (the person receiving the action).
  • Example: Whom did you call?
    (Here, ‘whom’ is the object of the verb ‘call’).
  • Tip: To decide whether to use ‘who’ or ‘whom’, try substituting the sentence with he/she or him/her:
  • If he/she fits, use who.
  • If him/her fits, use whom.
  • Example:
    • He called me. → Who called me?
    • You called him. → Whom did you call?

  1. Relative Clauses with ‘Who’
  • ‘Who’ is also used to introduce relative clauses that give more information about a person.
    Examples:
  • The girl who sings well is joining the choir.
  • The teacher who helped me was very kind.
  • Common Error: Confusing ‘who’ and ‘that’ in relative clauses.
  • Incorrect: The boy that is talking is my friend.
  • Correct: The boy who is talking is my friend.

  1. Common Pronoun Errors with ‘Who’
  • Misplacing ‘Who’ as an Object Pronoun:
    Incorrect: The coach asked who the players were passing the ball to.
    Corrected: The coach asked whom the players were passing the ball to.
  • Using ‘Who’ Incorrectly in Questions:
    Incorrect: Whom is coming to the party?
    Corrected: Who is coming to the party? (Here, ‘who’ is the subject of the sentence.)